Spicy chicken, black beans, corn, cheeses and peppers
$10.99
Jumbo Pretzel
Served with 3 dipping sauces
$11.99
Fried Onion Ring Tower
Served with creamy horseradish sauce
$11.99
Cajun Shrimp Dip
Spicy shrimp in a cream cheese blend, served with pita chips
$13.99
Fried Pickle Chips
$8.99
Fried Wontons
With sauce on the side
$8.99
Chips and Salsa
$5.99
French Onion Soup
A hearty broth thick with sautéed onions, topped with a lid of melted cheese
Bowl$6.79
Cup$5.59
Soup of the Day
Ask your server for today’s fresh-made selection
Bowl$6.79
Cup$5.59
Served with warm garlic toast upon request
Walnut Chicken Salad Plate
Our freshly made chicken salad with tender chicken, walnuts, apples, seasonings and mayonnaise. Served on a bed of lettuce with assorted fresh fruit and hard-boiled egg
$15.99
Beef Taco Salad
Seasoned ground beef on a bed of lettuce topped with cheddar cheese, tomatoes, and black olives. Served in a taco bowl with tortilla chips. Sour cream and salsa on the side
$15.99
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken and romaine lettuce, topped with parmesan cheese and croutons. Tossed in Caesar dressing
$15.99
Salmon Caesar Salad
Salmon and romaine lettuce, topped with Parmesan cheese and croutons. Tossed in Caesar dressing
$18.99
Fried Chicken Salad
Tomatoes, crumbled bacon, and cheddar cheese tossed with fresh lettuce mix, topped with fried chicken
$15.99
Grilled Chicken Cobb Salad
Char-grilled chicken breast, bacon, hard-boiled, cheddar cheese, black olives and tomato
$15.99
Grilled or Blackened Mahi Salad
Over mixed greens with cheddar and Monterrey Jack cheese
$17.99
Homemade Shrimp Salad
Served with fresh fruit on a bed of lettuce
$15.99
Fresh Garden Salad
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, cheddar cheese and croutons
$6.99
Our loaded burgers are prepared from 100% fresh ground chuck. Each includes French fries
Jeremiah’s Supreme Burger
Juicy all-beef burger loaded with sautéed onions, peppers and mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese and bacon
$15.99
California Bacon Cheeseburger
A hot and juicy burger with melted American cheese and crispy bacon
$15.99
Blackened Bleu Cheese & Bacon Burger
A seasoned blackened burger with crisp bacon and bleu cheese crumbles
$15.99
Whiskey Glazed Burger
Fresh burger topped with bacon and smoked cheddar with lettuce, tomato and onion
$15.99
Hamburger
Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle
$13.99
Rooney Burger
Fresh burger topped with sautéed mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese
$15.99
Classic Cheeseburger
Fresh ground beef burger topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and melted cheese. Simply delicious!
$14.99
Bison Burger
Topped with smoked Gouda cheese
$18.99
Patty Melt
Juicy burger with sautéed onions and double the cheese on grilled rye bread
$15.99
Short Rib Brisket Burger
Topped with smoked cheddar and bacon
$16.99
Pepperjack and Bacon Burger
With fried jalapeños, topped with Boom Boom sauce
$15.99
Served with French fries
Crab Cake Sandwich
Maryland-style crab cake made with jumbo lump crabmeat. Served with tartar sauce on the side
$18.99
Fried Grouper
Grouper lightly breaded and flash-fried. Served on a grilled roll with
tartar sauce
$17.99
Reuben, Reuben
Lean corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread
$15.99
French Dip
Tender roast beef, shaved and piled on a fresh-baked deli roll with provolone cheese. Served with au jus
$15.99
Philly Steak
Choice of sliced sirloin or grilled chicken. Served with grilled onions and mushrooms, topped with melted Swiss cheese. Served on a fresh-baked deli roll
$15.99
Deluxe Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Topped with sautéed mushrooms, peppers, onions and cheddar cheese
$17.99
Cuban Sandwich
House-smoked pork with ham, mayo, mustard, Swiss and American cheese with pickles on Cuban bread
$16.99
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
House-smoked pork with ham, mayo, mustard, Swiss and American cheese with pickles on Cuban bread
$14.99
spicy
Tenderloin Steak Sandwich
With Onions, mushrooms, peppers, and Swiss cheese. Served on a ciabatta roll with au jus for dipping
$18.99
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
With pepperjack cheese
$14.99
BLT
On toasted white bread
$13.99
Island Fish Sandwich
Grilled mahi topped with island slaw and provolone cheese
$16.99
The DaVinci
Pressed Italian sandwich! Salami, ham, crisp bacon and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato and our special Italian mayo
$14.99
Grilled Chicken Chimichurri Sandwich
Topped with smoked Gouda cheese
$14.99
Smoked Pork on Toasted Roll
Served with barbecue sauce on the side
$14.99
Italian Turkey BLT
Shaved turkey on fresh Ciabatta roll with fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, bacon and Italian mayo
$15.99
Grilled Fish Tacos (3)
Three flour tortillas filled with grilled mahi, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and our sweet chile sauce. Served with French fries
$14.99
Served with warm garlic toast upon request
Shepherd’s Pie
The ultimate casserole stuffed full of beef, potatoes, corn and cheese
$16.99
Alabama Country-Fried Steak
Tender sirloin steak lightly breaded, fried and served with mashed potatoes, brown gravy, and vegetable of the day
$16.99
Chopped Steak
Tender chopped steak topped with sautéed mushrooms and gravy. Served with mashed potatoes and vegetable
$17.99
Fried Pork Chops
Served with mashed potatoes and vegetables
$18.99
Chicken and Dumplings
Slow-cooked chicken and vegetables in a creamy stew with piping hot dumplings topped with a fresh buttermilk biscuit. Served with one side
$15.99
Baked Chicken Pot Pie
Pot pie with fresh chicken and garden vegetables in a rich creamy sauce baked until golden brown
$15.99
Pot Roast
A generous serving of slow-roasted beef, vegetables and mashed potatoes
$17.99
Seafood Pot Pie
Shrimp, scallop, fish, and crab meat in a seafood stew. Topped with a puffed pastry
$18.99
Served with your choice of two
Served with your choice of two sides:
Fresh garden salad
Soup du jour
Creamy coleslaw
Baked potato
French fries
Mashed potatoes
Rice
Vegetable of the day
Applesauce
Sweet Potato or Loaded potato$1
Honey-Fried Chicken
Four pieces of tender chicken dipped in our own sweet honey-batter and fried to a golden brown
$16.99
Grilled Liver and Onions
Tender baby beef liver cooked to perfection. Topped with plenty of sautéed onions
$16.99
Chicken Key Largo
Key-licious! Chicken breast smothered with sautéed mushrooms, onions, bacon, mozzarella and Colby cheese
$17.99
Chicken Fingers Basket
Tender chicken fingers served with French fries and your choice of dipping sauce
$14.99
Buffalo Chicken Wing Basket
Eight wings served with French fries, celery, carrot sticks and bleu cheese dressing
$14.99
Seafood Combo Basket
Golden-fried shrimp, fish fillets and crispy clam strips. served with French fries and your choice of dipping sauce
$17.99
Shrimp and Rib Basket
Baby back ribs and hand-breaded, fried shrimp. Served with French fries
$18.99
Fish Basket
A pub tradition. Batter-fried fish fillets served with French fries and tartar sauce
$14.99
Shrimp Basket
Hand-breaded shrimp served with French fries and cocktail sauce
$15.99
Fried Grouper Basket
Fried Grouper bites served with French fries and coleslaw
$16.99
Shrimp and Scallop Basket
Breaded and fried to order
$17.99
Served with your choice of two sides:
Fresh garden salad
Soup du jour
Creamy coleslaw
Baked potato
French fries
Mashed potatoes
Rice
Vegetable of the day
Applesauce
Sweet Potato or Loaded potato$1
Salmon
Fresh pan-seared salmon cooked with our house seasoning
$24.99
Add 4 fried shrimp$6
Grouper
Fresh grilled or blackened grouper caught in the Gulf
$28.99
Broiled Haddock
Dive into this fish favorite! A generous-sized flaky haddock fillet broiled to perfection
$23.99
Crab Cake Dinner
Two homemade jumbo lump crab cakes served with rémoulade
$28.99
Fried Haddock
Made famous over 50 years ago at the Penfield Tavern. Served with French fries and coleslaw
$23.99
Fried Shrimp
Everyone’s favorite! Gulf shrimp, breaded and fried to a delicate golden brown, served with our homemade zesty cocktail sauce
$20.99
Broiled Seafood Platter
A big platter loaded with haddock, shrimp, sea scallops, and deviled crab
$29.99
Fried Seafood Platter
A big platter loaded with all your favorites, including shrimp, scallops, clams and a fish fillet
$28.99
Buttermilk Fried Catfish
Served with French fries and coleslaw
$19.99
Served with your choice of two
Fresh garden salad
Soup du jour
Creamy coleslaw
Baked potato
French fries
Mashed Potatoes
Rice
Vegetable of the day
Applesauce
Sweet Potato
Loaded baked potato$1
Prime Rib of Beef
You’ll appreciate the rich flavor and moist, tender taste of slow-roasted aged USDA prime meat ribeye
10 oz.$26.99
16 oz.$35.99
Add 4 fried shrimp$6
10 oz. Jack Daniel’s Sirloin
Juicy center-cut sirloin cooked to order and finished with a Jack Daniel’s glaze. Served sizzling, topped with sautéed fresh mushrooms
$22.99
Add 4 fried shrimp$6
Jeremiah’s Special 8 oz. Sirloin
This tender cut of beef packs great steak flavor. Cooked to order
$19.99
Smothered Steak
8 oz sirloin with sautéed mushrooms, bacon, cheddar, Monterey Jack cheese. Topped with onion straws
$21.99
Filet Mignon
Most tender of all cuts. Cooked to your specifications. Topped with garlic butter
6 oz.$28.99
10 oz.$38.99
14 oz. Ribeye
Aged USDA center-cut ribeye
$27.99
Baby Back Ribs
Tender, slow-cooked baby back ribs topped with our own barbecue sauce
Full order$22.99
Half order$14.99
14 oz New York Strip
Aged center-cut steak. Cooked to order
$27.99
Served with salsa and sour cream. Add refried beans and rice - $1.99
Sizzling Steak or Chicken Fajitas
A half-pound of chicken or steak served sizzling with grilled onions and peppers. Served with cheese, tomatoes, lettuce and flour tortillas
Steak$19.99
Chicken$18.99
Combination$19.99
Beef Chimmi
Made with our 60-year-old recipe - deep fried then topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, black olives. Served with refried beans and rice
$17.99
Arroz Con Pollo
Grilled chicken over yellow rice, topped with white queso cheese sauce with refried beans
$17.99
Steak or Chicken Quesadilla
Jumbo flour tortilla stuffed with chicken or steak, cheddar and Monterrey jack cheeses and grilled
Steak$14.99
Chicken$13.99
Make it Loaded with mushrooms, sautéed onions, bacon and grilled green peppers for an additional$1.99
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
Filled with shrimp, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and our new Bang Bang sauce. Served with French fries
$14.99
spicy
Grilled Fish Tacos (3)
Three flour tortillas filled with grilled mahi, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese, and our sweet chile sauce. Served with French fries
$14.99
Lasagna
Our own recipe, better than your mother's! Served with a house salad
$17.99
4 Cheese Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast fried and topped with marinara sauce and our blend of four cheeses: Romano, mozzarella, parmesan, and Monterrey jack. Served over pasta and served with one side choice
$18.99
Chicken Marsala
Fresh mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce served with mashed potatoes and a salad
$18.99
Pepperoni Cheese Pizza
12” pizza loaded with sauce, cheese and pepperoni
$13.99
Cheese Pizza
12” pizza topped with cheese
$12.99
Ages 12 years old and younger. Served with French fries and small kids' drink
Your choice 8.99
Chicken Nuggets
Mac N’ Cheese
Cheese Quesadilla
Cheeseburger
Shrimp Basket
Grilled Cheese
Corn Dog
Chocolate Cake
Carrot Cake
Key Lime Pie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Wines available by the bottle upon request
Blush and Red Wine
White Zinfandel, Estrella, CA
Fresh-picked strawberries, and hints of cranberry on the delightful finish
$7.95
Sangue Di Guida, Decordi, Italy
An effervescent red wine that occurs naturally. Full bodied, accompanied by violets, raspberry and blueberry jam notes creating a smooth finish
$8.95
Merlot, Estrella River, CA
Opens with dark ripe blackberries and cherries with mild oak on the smooth finish
$7.95
Pinot Noir, Scarlet of Paris, France
Aromas and flavors of black cherry and raspberry fruit and a hint of vanilla, with a long smooth finish
$8.95
Montepulciano, Terre Di Poggo, Italy
Medium-bodied packed with wonderful flavors of dark cherry, blackberry with soft velvety tannins with a well rounded finish
$9.95
Cabernet, Estrella River, CA
Flavors and aromas of ripe plum, black cherry and cassis that compliment the finish
$7.95
Cabernet, Never Look Back, SA
A full-bodied and richly textured, with intense black fruit, well-integrated hints of oak on the finish. You’ll never look back!
$11
Moore Creek, Rose
California Flavors and aromas of cherry, watermelon, red berry fruit, pomegranate and raspberry with a refreshing finish
$8.95
White Wine
Prosecco, Franzie & Cratzi, Italy 187 Split
Opens with a lovely aromas of pressed wildflower, ripe apple notes with a lively finish
$9.95
Moscato, Culitos, Chile
Well-balanced combination of ripe peach, juicy apricot and hints of zesty citrus
$8.95
Mango Moscato, Culitos, Chile
Layers of ripe mango, with hints of peach and melon with a crisp finish
$9.95
Riesling, Fritz, Germany
Delightfully fragrant with floral and mineral notes, luscious and fruity with pleasant sweetness
$7.95
Pinot Grigio, Bel Vento, Italy
Bright and lively aromas and flavors of crisp green apple with zesty citrus notes on the finish
$8.95
Pinot Grigio, Bordinise, Italy
Opens with crisp citrus notes and green apple with a smooth finish
$7.95
Sauvignon Blanc, Hooks Bay, NZ
An elegant expression of the Marlborough region, vibrant tropical notes, bright melon, white peach and citrus notes, with a crisp finish
$10.95
Chardonnay, Estrella River, CA
Aromas and flavors of apple, pear and tropical fruits with a hint of citrus on the finish
$7.95
Chardonnay, Seal Rock, CA
Aromas and flavors of tropical fruits, caramel apple, honey dew melons with a hint of citrus
